Tag Archives: research ethics

When disclosure rules are not enough: authorial warrant and judgment in ai-supported scholarship

Editorial policies increasingly require authors to disclose substantive uses of generative AI, but such requirements commonly focus on whether, where, and how a model was used. Even function-specific disclosure may locate a model in the research or writing process without showing how its outputs entered scholarly judgment, how they were evaluated, or whether contributors can reconstruct the relevant reasoning and defend resulting claims without treating those outputs as sufficient justification. Drawing on research ethics, AI disclosure policy, human–model interaction, and researcher formation, this article argues that disclosure documents model use, whereas responsible use requires claim-level authorial warrant: a contributor’s capacity to understand, justify, and defend claims within their contribution. The article distinguishes cognitive delegation, in which model outputs shape substantive choices, interpretations, or justifications, from routine delegation, which does not ordinarily bear on the substance of judgment. Its conceptual contribution is to link the epistemic role of outputs that shape judgment to the function-appropriate evaluation required to justify decisions and retain warrant for resulting claims. It then repurposes disclosure categories as a claim-sensitive ex ante heuristic, mapping six recurrent research functions to risks, forms of oversight, and formative questions for recognising cognitive delegation and selecting function-appropriate evaluation. The article contributes to the ethics of information technology by clarifying when AI-supported scholarship remains under responsible human judgment and when cognitive delegation threatens the epistemic basis of authorship.

The Anatomy of a Scientific Review: Surviving the Ultimate Judgment in Computer Science and Medical Sciences

You hit “Submit” and then… silence. Months of work, hundreds of edits, one click—and the long wait for a verdict from those enigmatic figures: Reviewer 1, Reviewer 2… It’s one of the most stressful moments in a researcher’s life. But what actually happens on the other side? Peer review is the backbone of science—a quality-control system meant to ensure that published work is important, original, and rigorous (Sense about Science).

Continue reading →

A Researcher’s Roadmap: A Practical Framework for Rigorous Science

After many years spent in research, the scientific process—from idea to publication—becomes second nature. However, this intuition, though invaluable, deserves to be structured. The desire to describe this workflow stems not only from a need to better understand my own work but also from the desire to create a map that can help others navigate this complex terrain.

One inspiration was a humorous but accurate list from the book “We Have No Idea: A Guide to the Unknown Universe” by Jorge Cham and Daniel Whiteson:

  1. Organize what you know
  2. Look for patterns
  3. Ask questions
  4. Buy a tweed jacket with elbow patches

However, scientific work is, above all, the art of asking the right questions. It’s not about “beating the baseline” but about understanding a phenomenon. The question “why?” is a researcher’s compass. In turn, understanding often means the ability to reconstruct a mechanism (e.g., by implementing code or a formal proof), although in some areas of mathematics, a complete, verifiable line of reasoning is sufficient.

I have noticed that whether I am writing an empirical paper in Natural Language Processing (NLP) or a systematic review with a meta-analysis, a common skeleton lies beneath the surface. The result of these observations is the working framework below, which attempts to visualize this skeleton.

Continue reading →